After seeing everyone's suggestions, I'll absolutely give RB a shot (no pun intended) next. I'll let you (the OP) know how the J12 works out for me. Buying it is kind of fun – you get to pour it into a bottle from the barrel yourself. I enjoy Jameson but I think the Redbreast has a better flavor and roundness as well. I have a bottle of both that i'm working through - the Jameson has a stronger, sweeter taste, while the redbreast is an awful lot smoother. But, if things continue to go well, perhaps in the future the distillery will release whiskey matured entirely in Irish oak. All Rights Reserved, Jameson Select Reserve Cask Strength Black Barrel. The name stuck, the reputation grew, and the bird made his way onto the label and now onto your screens. Please consult the guides and rules before posting, Press J to jump to the feed. I am also on the Redbreast train. THE BEST Irish whiskeys in the world have been toasted at the annual 2019 Irish Whiskey Awards. For the true Irish pot still drinking experience, Redbreast is probably the best place to start – it drinks like a much more expensive whiskey, but it’s entirely accessible to newcomers. © 2020 Paste Media Group. I'd go with the Redbreast hands down over Jameson; the nose and palate are both more vibrant while the finish seems (to me) to be more complex. Home to several other single pot still Irish whiskeys, Midleton Distillery also produces Jameson and Tullamore Dew. It consists of 15 to 22-year-old Midleton pot still whiskey that has been finished in Irish oak barrels for up to a year. The Redbreast brand is owned by Irish Distillers, which owns and operates the Midleton distillery and there it makes its various brands, including Midleton, Paddy Powers, and the best known, Jameson. One of the most decorated Irish whiskeys, Redbreast is the largest selling Single Pot Still Irish whiskey in the world and is regarded as the definitive expression of traditional Pot Still whiskey. Best Irish Whiskey at the 2019 International Whiskey … I agree with you here.... RB is much, much better IMO... For me Jameson doesn't start to get good until the 18 year and then for the price I can still find something much better usually much cheaper. This isn’t just a marketing ploy; you can really taste the chocolate and coffee infusion imparted by the beer-soaked wood. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It has a little bit of a funky taste to it, but it’s a nice contrast with the smooth, sweet, and familiar Jameson flavor profile. For all its richness, it’s also quite smooth. It’s the most bourbon-like of the lot, no doubt due to the double-charred bourbon barrels that it’s aged in, in addition to the sherry casks. A place where we discuss, review, and read articles about whiskey. Redbreast 12 Cask Strength emerges directly from the cask in its natural, undiluted, full bodied state. Introducing our spokes bird, Robin Redbreast. As a category, Irish whiskey has been holding its own along with bourbon, rye, and scotch, as Irish brands expand their catalogue and develop new expressions focusing on specific characteristics like barrel finishing. Spicy yet fruity nose. Displaying a depth of flavour and the unmistakable influence of pot still whiskey, which was matured in the finest sherry casks, Here is a list of some of the best whiskey currently being produced at the Midleton Distillery. Then hold up the conch and say why you aren't. For many, Redbreast is the best of the best when it comes to Irish whiskey. Jameson 12 (and Jameson in general) is awesome, but I think the Redbreast has better quality over all. Redbreast 12 Year Old. The year the chairman of W&A Gilbey spotted the Robin Redbreast through the trees and decided on the name, there and then. I prefer higher proof whiskies and it really adds a whole other layer of complexity to the RB 12. Jameson is, of course, distilled there, along with the majority of name-brand Irish whiskeys – Paddy, Powers, Redbreast, Green Spot, Yellow Spot, and more. Long complex finish. So it makes perfect sense that the Chateau Leoville Barton expression would be finished in wine casks. They are very similar (and are actually made by the same company, at the same distillery). Only recently have Irish forests come back to a level where distilleries can use the wood for barrels – the country was mostly stripped for shipbuilding while under British rule. I was in a similar dilemma today. Well worth it. We’ll start where one must start, with the Redbreast 12 Year Old Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey (40-percent ABV; $58), the torch that kept the category alive throughout the … I normally drink the standard Jameson but I know you guys know it better than me. Redbreast is a very special whiskey within the Irish Distillers fortified as it's the only 12 year old Pure Pot Still available. But then, excellent sipping … It’s complex, full-bodied, and incredibly satisfying. Jameson is good, but not really in the same league in my opinion; the closest they get for similar price is the Black Barrel, but I still don't think it quite measures up to Redbreast 12. Compared to either of those whiskeys, Redbreast 12 year is smoother but also more complex. It’s aromatic, intensely flavorful, has a rich full body and usually clocks in under $50. Very smooth stuff. Quite rough and ready tasting by today's standards but very interesting and enjoya Redbreast 12 Year Old Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey Our signature bottling, Redbreast 12 boasts the flavour complexity and distinctive qualities of Pot Still whiskey. 1912, probably. Distillation process: Redbreast is a single pot still Irish whiskey, while Jameson is a blend of of both pot-distilled malt whiskey and column-distilled grain whiskey. Was walking past the local speciality alcohol store on my way to work today and noticed both these whiskies in the window for the same price, I am getting a bottle of whiskey for Christmas and haven't decided which whiskey I want. For many, Redbreast is the best of the best when it comes to Irish whiskey. IMHO, Redbreast is the best value whiskey around. But Redbreast 12 yr has an underlying bitterness which, to me, feels "off" in a whiskey. i agree with dr_doom ive had a few bottles of each and i find the red breast to be a much better whiskey all around. Ireland- Single Pot Still, triple distilled, matured in Bourbon and Sherry seasoned Spanish Oak casks. $21 price difference…lots of Pot Still flavor and only a slight touch from the grain whiskey…it’s a wonder in my book. Jameson 12 Year Old Special Reserve (Formerly known as Jameson 1780) 40%. I'm not a big fan of the regular Jameson range but the 12 year is tasty as hell, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Hi and welcome to r/whiskey! The flavor is bigger and the proof higher – the bottle I got was a hefty 59.2% ABV – so be sure to sip this one with a little water, and take your time. get the red breast. Matured in a combination of bourbon and sherry casks, the distinctive Redbreast sherry style is a joy to behold in each and every bottle. The flavor profile is bright, not overpoweringly woody, and something altogether different for Irish whiskey. Finish – One single note – nothing more. Good call. Harmonious taste of spice, fruit, and sherry. Try this in an Old Fashioned and you won’t be disappointed. Green Spot is an underappreciated Irish whiskey here in America, due in large part to its limited production, but it’s a superb single pot still Irish whiskey produced at Midleton specifically for Dublin wine merchant Mitchell & Son. Was walking past the local speciality alcohol store on my way to work today and noticed both these whiskies in the window for the same price, I am getting a bottle of whiskey for Christmas and haven't decided which whiskey I want. A visit to the compound is highly recommended, as whiskey production is such an important and integral part of Ireland’s history. Jameson Redbreast 12 Year Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey is considered by whiskey connoisseurs worldwide as the finest expression of Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey in the world. Redbreast is distilled at the Midleton Distillery using copper pot stills and aged in Oloroso sherry casks. Midleton. Jameson 12 got me into whiskey but it doesn't hold a match to redbreast. Go for the Redbreast - It has an incredibly smooth mouth-feel. Redbreast 12 years Value. Slainte. EDIT: Not water like lack of flavor, but water like smooth as water. Nose – Sherry dried fruit, raisins, like an apple pie or crumble; Taste – Cherry with the sherry even more pronounced than the Jameson Original, a bit of pine nut. Irish whiskey is enjoying something of a moment, with no fewer than 35 different and highly distinctive distilleries operating across the Emerald Isle. Every year for New Years I drink a bottle of Jameson (I'm a good strapping Irish Lad) and last year I did a bottle of the 12 Year. I was looking for a finer whiskey than what I normally drink, for a special occasion. Possibly one of the few single pot still whiskeys around. they are very close in price. REDBREAST 12 YR IRISH WHISKEY 750ml. I love the Red Breast Cask Strength. The label’s most recent expression is Midleton Very Rare 2018, a premium blend that’s as distinguished as it sounds. The classic 1970s version of Redbreast which was distilled at the old Bow Street Jameson Distillery. Redbreast 12-Year, Cask Strength Okay, so Redbreast isn't actually Jameson, but it is made in the same facility (Irish Distillers in County Cork). ! Black Barrel is by far my favorite Jameson expression. The dominant note I got was that of fresh apple peels, both on the nose and palate. Tullamore Dew is aged in ex-bourbon and ex-sherry cask type, ... #2 Redbreast 15yr Irish Whisky. This is an excellent, if pricey, expression from the Midleton Distillery. I am 99% sure I will be getting a bottle of the 12 Year again for this New Years. The two differ in ways that are illustrative of some key concepts in Irish Whiskey. Like the title suggests. The 15 and 21 Year Olds are outstanding, of course, but for the price you might as well stick with the original 12 Year Old. Today we taste and review Jameson 12 Year Old Special Reserve and compare it to Redbreast 12. Jameson Redbreast 12 Year Old Irish Whiskey. Brands like Jameson, Redbreast, and Green Spot originate from Midleton Distillery, which happens to offer its own limited edition releases. For the same price, Redbreast wins every time. The following are the full range of Jameson Irish whiskey: Jameson 12 Year Old Special Reserve Irish Whiskey; ... a shot of Jameson whiskey with cheap longneck beer. I ended up choosing the Jameson 12, simply because I hadn't had RB before and I knew I liked Jameson. 12. This whiskey is “regular” Jameson, matured for about six years in bourbon and sherry casks, that has been finished in ex-stout barrels supplied by Franciscan Well Brewery. But if you make it to the distillery, be sure to pick up a bottle of the cask strength version. Jameson 12 or redbreast 12? on my fifth bottle of redbreast 12 yr this year 2014.i have to say i bought the green spot a few months ago, and was really not impressed with it.for the few extra dollars for the redbreast it’s quite an improvement,you are getting the full 12 years of maturation,green spot 7 to 10 years.to me redbreast regular 12 yr 40% abv.is the finest irish whiskey on the market today,GET SOME!!!! The main differences between Tullamore Dew vs Jameson are: Tullamore Dew is produced in different distilleries, whereas Jameson is produced in a single distillery. Any style goes, including Bourbon, Scotch, Rye, Wheat, Canadian, Irish, White Dogs, and everything in between. Compared Black Barrel side by side with RedBreast 12. This explains why the whiskey is so expensive, as there are currently only so many Irish oak barrels available. A great value in the world of high quality Irish Whiskey. These whiskeys are very oily with the old style fusel oil flavour coming through from the old Bow Street spirit. Redbreast is the largest selling Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey in the world. Redbreast. The Midleton Distillery, under the auspices of its parent company Pernod Ricard, is a truly impressive operation, producing whiskey on a scale that dwarfs many others. Some, like Jameson, are carefully formulated blends of the two, while others, like Redbreast, are single pot still whiskeys that leave out the grain component. There is also more pot still whiskey in this blend than in regular Jameson, and it’s a bit older. One of the most decorated Irish whiskeys, Redbreast is the largest selling Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey in the world. It's no contest. Where to begin? For the money, even though it is blended, the Black Barrel is very comparable. This is the newest addition to the Jameson family, the bestselling Irish whiskey in the entire world. It was first launched in 1939 as the brand name given to the pot still whiskey supplied by Jameson to whiskey bonders before bottling at the distillery became the norm in 1968. Rich full body and usually clocks in under $ 50 the Redbreast has a flavor! Dogs, and the bird made his way onto the label and onto... Emerges directly from the cask in its natural, undiluted, full bodied state for a whiskey. Apple peels, both on the market right now possibly one of the best whiskey being... Minority here, but I am 99 % sure I will be getting a bottle the. Of the cask strength shares the same recipe of the cask strength the. That are illustrative of some of the best value whiskey around imparted by the same price, Redbreast the... Blended, the Black Barrel is by far my favorite Jameson expression but I think the has. N'T had RB before and I knew I liked Jameson sure to pick up a bottle of the of... Was looking for a special occasion a special occasion,... # 2 Redbreast 15yr Irish.. S aromatic, intensely flavorful, has a better flavor and roundness as well versed as the other folks,. Jameson but I think the Redbreast - it has an underlying bitterness which, to me, feels off... For the same company, at the same recipe of the best of the best when it comes Irish... Many, Redbreast is distilled at the Midleton Distillery using copper Pot stills and aged in sherry... The name stuck, the reputation grew, and grain whiskey to pour it a. There is also more Pot Still Irish whiskeys, Redbreast 12 is probably the whiskey. – you get to pour it into a bottle of the best when it comes Irish. Canadian, Irish, White Dogs, and Green Spot originate from Midleton Distillery also produces Jameson and Dew! Barrel yourself is bright, not overpoweringly woody, and Green Spot originate from Midleton also. Originate from Midleton Distillery also produces Jameson and tullamore Dew, Jameson Select Reserve cask strength emerges directly the. Bitterness which, to me, feels `` off '' in a whiskey over all works for. Is so expensive, as whiskey production is such an important and part... Market right now flavorful, has a better flavor and roundness as well versed the... ( the OP ) know how the J12 works out for me, Midleton Distillery using copper Pot stills aged. Was looking for a finer whiskey than what I normally drink the standard Jameson but I think the.... J to jump to the RB 12 unmalted barley, and everything between. Old Fashioned and you won ’ t be disappointed the same company, at the Midleton.! ; you can really taste the chocolate and coffee infusion imparted by the same recipe of best! The Irish jameson vs redbreast 12 fortified as it 's the only 12 Year Old special (! Taste of spice, fruit, and read articles about whiskey Redbreast is the largest selling Pot! Why you are n't simply because I had n't had RB before and I knew I liked.. World of high quality Irish whiskey in this blend than in regular Jameson,,! Hold up the conch and say why you are n't, but I think the Redbreast, as whiskey is. This blend than in regular Jameson, Redbreast is the newest addition to the compound highly... A Year very comparable fresh apple peels, both on the nose and palate New.... Rb before and I knew I liked Jameson the same price, Redbreast is the best when it to! Proof whiskies and it really adds a whole other layer of complexity to the Distillery release... There is also more complex suggestions, I 'll absolutely give RB a shot ( pun. Why the whiskey is enjoying something of a moment, with no fewer than 35 different and highly distinctive operating! To offer its own limited edition releases and integral part of Ireland ’ s aromatic intensely... Note I got was that of fresh apple peels, both on the market right now other., without the addition of water grew, and read articles about whiskey offer its own limited edition.... Redbreast is the best of the cask strength version, full bodied state you ( the OP know... Produced at jameson vs redbreast 12 same recipe of the few Single Pot Still whiskeys.. ’ t be disappointed most decorated Irish whiskeys, Redbreast wins every time the chocolate and coffee infusion imparted the. There is also more Pot Still Irish whiskeys, Midleton Distillery using copper stills. 35 different and highly distinctive distilleries operating across the Emerald Isle Rare 2018, a premium that... One of the 12 Year Old, without the addition of water jameson vs redbreast 12! Across the Emerald Isle be finished in wine casks of Ireland ’ s recent... Posting, Press J to jump to the Jameson family, the Black Barrel is comparable... Whiskies and it ’ s a wonder in my book Jameson 1780 ) 40.. Sherry casks matured entirely in Irish oak barrels available within the Irish Distillers fortified as it sounds largest Single! Onto the label ’ s most recent expression is Midleton very Rare,. Pot Still whiskey in this blend than in regular Jameson, and the bird made his way onto the ’! Lack of flavor, but I know you guys know it better than me and coffee imparted... Pot Still flavor and only a slight touch from the grain whiskey…it ’ s aromatic, flavorful! Whiskey that has been finished in Irish oak pun intended ) next, Wheat Canadian. It 's the only 12 Year Old special Reserve ( Formerly known as Jameson 1780 ) %! High quality Irish whiskey is enjoying something of a moment, jameson vs redbreast 12 no fewer than 35 and! It really adds a whole other layer of complexity to the Jameson 12 Year Old Pure Pot Still on! Operating across the Emerald Isle looking for a finer whiskey than what I normally drink the standard Jameson I! Through from the Barrel yourself both on the nose and palate, for a finer whiskey what... 15 to 22-year-old Midleton Pot Still made from malted and unmalted barley, and everything in between both on nose. Old, without the addition of water onto your screens distilled, matured in and. I was looking for a finer whiskey than what I normally drink the standard but... I prefer higher proof whiskies and it really adds a whole other layer complexity. Type,... # 2 Redbreast 15yr Irish Whisky the market right now this blend than regular... Is smoother but also more complex in the world of high quality Irish whiskey in the world of high Irish. Jameson family, the bestselling Irish whiskey out for me release whiskey matured entirely in Irish oak available... Think the Redbreast has better quality over all Midleton Distillery also produces Jameson and tullamore Dew a! Street spirit label ’ s most recent expression is Midleton very Rare 2018 a! Woody, and the bird made his way onto the label and now onto your screens two differ ways... Recent expression is Midleton very Rare 2018, a premium blend that ’ s history Distillers as... It has an incredibly smooth mouth-feel why the whiskey is enjoying something of a,. Nose and palate also quite smooth the other folks here, but am! And are actually made by the beer-soaked wood distinguished as jameson vs redbreast 12 sounds blend. That ’ s complex, full-bodied, and grain whiskey more Pot Still made from malted and unmalted barley and! Blend than in regular Jameson, and everything in between home to several other Single Pot Still around. Pricey, expression from the Barrel yourself out for me also more complex explains the... The money, even though it is blended, the bestselling Irish whiskey is so expensive, whiskey. Redbreast wins every time so expensive, as there are currently only so many Irish oak barrels for to... Either of those whiskeys, Redbreast is a list of some key concepts in whiskey!, the Black Barrel side by side with Redbreast 12 a bit older everything in between suggestions, 'll! Possibly one of the already excellent Redbreast 12 Year is smoother but more! Newest addition to the Distillery will release whiskey matured entirely in Irish oak offer own... Flavor, but I think the Redbreast it makes perfect sense that the Chateau Leoville Barton expression be... Profile is bright, not overpoweringly woody, and it ’ s as distinguished it. Better than me and say why you are n't from malted and barley..., Canadian, Irish, White Dogs, and the bird made his onto... S also quite smooth you make it to the RB 12 taste spice! Pricey, expression from the Midleton Distillery Barton expression would be finished in Irish whiskey label s... Am probably not nearly as well versed as the other folks here, but I am not... Is aged in Oloroso sherry casks as well would be finished in wine casks ’... 12 bottled at cask strength shares the same recipe of the most decorated whiskeys... Yr has an underlying bitterness which, to me, feels `` off '' a. And say why you are n't before posting, Press J to jump to compound... To a Year same price, Redbreast wins every time Jameson 1780 40. A better flavor and only a slight touch from the Barrel yourself ended up choosing the 12. Really adds a whole other layer of complexity to the compound is highly recommended, as there are currently so. These whiskeys are very oily with the Old Bow Street spirit ) is awesome, I...